Einstein
on Dowsing - Letters
The first letter
concerns communication between Albert Einstein, and Mr.
Peisach of South
Norwalk Conneticut.
The second, includes a conversation Albert had
with Rabinranath Tagore
(Bengali poet and Nobel Laureate), and also an
additional anecdote.
4 February 1946
"Mr. Herman E.
Peisach
32 Flax Hill Road
South Norwalk, Conn.
Dear
Sir:
I am a novice in this field that we are discussing. However, I
would
like to have you send me the reports. Even if I have no connection
with
scientist in this field, a recommendation from me could perhaps
be
effective, so that this subject could receive more
attention.
Very truly yours,
A. Einstein
The above letter was received by Mr. Peisach, with whose
kind permission
it, and the one below, are published, in reply to a letter
seeking Professor
Einstein's views on his father's papers. Peisach senior,
now deceased, was
a physician in Germany who had learned to use the dowsing
rod for diagnostic
purposes, and had become interested in the influence of
radiation from water
and mineral veins on health. Mr. Peisach wrote us that
by chance he had
tuned his TV set to the "Look at Us" program on the Danville
Convention, and
generously referred us to this correspondence. After
forwarding the reports
to Princeton, he received the following reply.
Translations are courtesy of
Tell Ehardt and the German Department of
Villanova University.
Dear Mr.
Peisach:
15 February 1946
I read with great interest the reports from your
father and I think
that they deserve attention. To publish them in the daily
press would have
little effect. However, if you send these reports to a
medical journal, you
will have to re-write some of the other aspects that are
not really
pertinent to this matter.
I know very well that many
scientists consider dowsing as they do
astrology, as a type of ancient
superstition. According to my conviction
this is, however, unjustified. The
dowsing rod is a simple instrument which
shows the reaction of the human
nervous system to certain factors which are
unknown to us at this time. That
the same circumstances can bring forth
nervous difficulties in breathing
appears entirely plausible. However, I do
not think there is any connection
with the occurrence of cancer. This
latter connection, if true, would not be
easy to prove with supporting
statistics.
If you submit the carefully
revised reports to a medical journal you
may attach a copy of my letter, so
that this matter will receive the
attention I feel it deserves.
Very truly yours,
A. Einstein
"A human being is a part of the whole, called by us
'Universe', a part
limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his
thoughts and
feelings as something separated from the rest - a kind of
optical delusion
of his consciousness. This delusion is a prison for us,
restricting us to
our personal desires and to affection for a few persons
nearest to us.
Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by
widening our
circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the
whole of nature
in its beauty."
-Albert Einstein
"I know very
well that many scientists consider dowsing as they do
astrology, as a type
of ancient superstition. According to my
conviction this is, however,
unjustified. The Dowsing rod is a
simple instrument which shows the
reaction of the human nervous
system to certain factors which are unknown to
us at this time."
-Albert Einstein
Conversation between Einstein and the Bengali poet
and Nobel Laureate
Rabinranath Tagore, Berlin, 1930:
Einstein: Do you believe that the divine is
isolated from the world?
Tagore: It is not isolated, the
infinite nature of man includes the universe.
Einstein: There
are two fundamental conceptions concerning the
nature of the universe; it is
considered to be either as a whole
inseparable from the vision of it which
man has, or as a reality
independent of our human
perception.
Tagore: When the universe is recognized as a
harmony according to
eternal man, it appears to one in its dimension of
beauty and truth.
Einstein: That is a conception of the universe
which depends entirely on man.
Tagore: There cannot be any
other conception: a world separate from
us does not exist; it is a relative
world the reality of which depends on our
consciousness.
Einstein: So, if there were no longer any
human beings, there
would, also, no longer be any beauty or
truth?
Tagore: No.
Einstein: I agree about
beauty but not about truth. Such is my
religion: there is
something real which is independent of man and a
truth concerning this
reality.
Tagore: A truth that would be independent of
humanity and having no
relation with it certainly does not
exist.
Einstein: Then, I am more religious that
you.
Many years ago, Herman Wolf was entertaining a guest at his
parents'
rural home near Bremen, Germany, when, in general
conversation, Wolf's
mother mentioned that a huge pond in their
garden was "leaking".
The
guest said he might be able to help and immediately fashioned
a forked
dowsing rod.
Taking the rod, he walked out to the pond and in a short
time
pinpointed the exact location of the underground flow that was
draining the pond. The Wolfs were delighted and even more so when
their guest proceeded to teach them the fine points of the art of
dowsing.
Herman Wolf was actually more amazed than delighted because
his
friend and guest was none other that the celebrated scientist Albert
Einstein.
-- George Cunningham-Tee
Toronto Sun
Syndicate